This soothing, fragrant beverage is a holiday classic. The longer the spices stew in the cider, the stronger the flavor, so taste periodically to check strength. Sachets of mulling spices are easy to create, impressive to give and fun to receive. Multiply this recipe to make a big batch. Then set out your ingredients into individual bowls, assembly-line-style, and cut the cheesecloth in advance so it’s easy to make many sachets at once.
Cut cheesecloth (Grade 60/very fine mesh works best) into 10×10-inch single-thickness squares and set aside. Lay 1 cheesecloth square flat on a table. Place all ingredients on the square. Then gather up the edges of the cloth and tie with a 10-inch piece of twine.
Pour apple cider into a large pot over medium heat.
Add sachet of Mulling Spices (do not open sachet), stirring to wet sachet.
Cook cider with sachet submerged 10 to 20 minutes without boiling, to taste.